






Traditional harvest feasts and celebrations giving thanks for surviving winter and its hardships have been held by native cultures around the world for thousands of years. A gathering between the Plymouth colonists and about 90 Wampanoag Indians has come to be known as the first Thanksgiving, though Native Americans had organized such gatherings for centuries before the Europeans arrived on American soil. What actually happened that day is clouded in history, but we do know that it was a feast held in the spirit of cooperation between the colonists and the Native Americans to celebrate a bountiful harvest.
These postcards selected from the Curt Teich Postcard Archives show an array of wild turkeys, some who have already met their fate, and others that seem overly confident, two downright patriotic, and oblivious to their Thanksgiving dinner destiny. Were turkeys part of the original feast held back in 1621 or just part of the holiday’s mythology? According to the most detailed description of that famous feast from A Journal of the Pilgrims at Plymouth by Edward Winslow, we do know that fowl and venison were surely on the menu. It’s very possible that geese, ducks and swans were also part of the “fowl” offerings that graced the table. Lobster, clams and even seals were plentiful at the time and also may have been a part of the harvest repast.
I’m afraid that stuffing and pumpkin pie were not on the menu, which would make my family very unhappy. The supply of flour the pilgrims had brought with them had dwindled and they did not yet have ovens. However, they may have eaten boiled pumpkin and due to the time of year, plums, berries, chestnuts, acorns, walnuts and dried peas and beans may have been available to them as well. There were no domestic cattle, therefore no milk products. Potatoes were still viewed as poisonous by the colonists, so those creamy mashed potatoes beloved by today’s Thanksgiving feasters were definitely not on the table. Cranberries, one of three fruits native to America along with blueberries and Concord grapes, may have been eaten dried but not in the sweet and tart concoction we call cranberry sauce. Though the Pilgrims had brought sugar with them on the Mayflower, it was probably a scarce commodity by the time of the feast.
The 1621 harvest feast attended by the Native Americans and Pilgrims at Plymouth lasted for three days and was a secular celebration, not the day of thanksgiving it has become. The participants engaged in traditional harvest festival activities such as dancing, singing and game playing. It was not repeated the next year nor did they have plans to make the event into anything more than it was, a time of gathering to celebrate a good harvest. It wasn’t until 1863 that President Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a national holiday, a tradition that has been upheld by every president since.
I took an informal poll of the Archives’ staff to see how they spend the Thanksgiving holiday. For most it is a day of family, food and football. For some the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade plays in the background while the food is prepared and as a lighthearted prelude to the hours of choreographed violence called football. There was a consensus on one element, though, the menu stays the same. An errant new dish may be introduced occasionally, only to be nixed for the next year’s lineup, but there is always turkey. One family forgoes the football and attends a movie, while another with three small children makes the rounds to both sides of the family and two full turkey dinners. My guess is that a lot of napping is happening in between visits. Whatever your Thanksgiving traditions may be, I hope your day is happy and your harvest is bountiful.















































